The New York Times laments the poor preparation of high school graduates but enthusiastically supports No Child Left Behind and applauds the continued federal mandate for annual testing. The editorial is a caricature of the criticism of high-stakes standardized testing. "If students are graduating with empty high school diplomas, it cannot be because there wasn't enough testing. The truth: "There is a federal testing program called the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) that reports on what U.S. students are learning every other year.Test score gains came to a crashing halt in 2015, as NCLB, Race to the Top and Common Core converged in a frenzy of exactly what the New York Times wants."