A tech lover recently told me that he and several colleagues have realized:
1. The Earth does not have enough energy, minerals or water to support AI, e-vehicles, solar PVs, industrial wind facilities and batteries. Not at the scale we dream to fulfill. Not with eight billion humans.
2. Expanding the Internet and AI ravages the Earth and wastes young brains.
I consider this man's honesty excellent news. If more people acknowledge that our electronic tools take from the Earth faster than it can replenish and waste faster than the Earth can absorb, maybe we could take a collective pause. We could question which manufactured goods are necessary and which ones are not. We could stop ravaging ecosystems, reduce production and consumption. We could have truth and reconciliation parties about our relationship with nature and ask each other for help in living within our bioregion's ecological limits. We could cultivate humility.
Meanwhile, reports about the technosphere's harms continue to flood my inbox. I do also get some Good News. Thanks for taking a look:
SOLAR PV PROBLEMS CONTINUE TO GLARE
In June, 2024, the Aratina Solar Project in Kern County CA will destroy 4,287 five-hundred-year-old Joshua trees to power 93,000 homes with "clean" (solar PV) energy.
According to a report by Sheffield Hallam University, "almost the entire global solar panel industry is implicated in the forced labor of Uyghurs and other Turkic and Muslim-majority peoples" who crush quartz rocks and work in coal-fueled furnaces to produce polysilicon for solar panels. Investors nor governments adequately address Uyghur forced labour risks in the renewable energy sector.
In Slavery Poisons Solar Industry's Supply Chains, Miles Pollard reports that roughly 80% of solar components are manufactured in China using slave labor.
See European Parliament resolutions regarding forced labor in China to make solar PVs. See the 2021 U.S. Uyghur Forced Labor Prevention Act, which expanded the mandate that all U.S. companies importing silicon from Xinjiang confirm supply chains free of forced labor. In June 2021, a US Withhold Release Order prevented imports containing silicon from Hoshine Silicon Industry Co. Ltd. and its subsidiaries from entering the U.S. until importing companies could prove they were not made with forced labor.
What to do? Solar corporations should obtain nearby communities' free, prior and informed consent before mining or smelting. They can use standards like the Silicon Valley Toxics Coalition's Solar Scorecard. The Solar Equipment Buyers' Guide for Supply Chain Traceability explains how manufacturers can track finished solar modules' material origins.
Before buying solar PVs, require the manufacturer to trace its supply chains.
Read Tuco's Child, a Substack written by a retired chemist who worked in nanomaterials, polymer chemistry, semi-conductor process engineering and the mining industry and treated wastewater from semiconductor effluent. See his photo essay, Fossil Fuels Create 1 Trillion Computer Chips per Year. Computer chips and solar panel wafers are both made from silicon. Making silicon is like working in a volcano. Every 50,000 tons of silicon produces 500,000 tons of CO2. (Solar PVs also use copper, aluminum, boron, phosphorous, PFAs and much more.) Since recycling solar panels is not feasible or economical, expect an avalanche of solar panels at the landfill near you (another fab photo essay from Tuco's Child).
(Note: You can view every article as one long page if you sign up as an Advocate Member, or higher).