During last year's presidential campaign, Donald Trump and Kamala Harris seemed to disagree on quite a few things. One thing they agreed on -- Trump reiterated his position in a speech in Las Vegas on January 26 -- is that the federal government should stop demanding income tax payments on tips.
Allow me to be ... well, probably far from the first ... person to say what a wonderful idea that is.
Usually the phrase "bipartisan agreement" raises the hairs on the back of my neck. When politicians from both "major parties" agree on something, anything, it's usually terrible news for the rest of us. "Bipartisanship" has given us everything from the warfare state to the surveillance state to the federal government's "Make America East Germany Again" immigration approach.
But IF we're going to have taxes (we shouldn't), and IF we're going to have income tax (we shouldn't), and IF that income tax excludes your gift of up to $19,000 per year per recipient (it does), then common sense tells us that your 15% gift to a restaurant server or $5 gift to a delivery worker, etc. shouldn't be taxed.
What are tips?
They're NOT part of the purchase price.
Chip Card Reader Tipping Options.
(Image by Wikipedia (commons.wikimedia.org), Author: Canadian2006) Details Source DMCA
You don't HAVE to give them, in any amount or at all.
They're. Gifts.
But the federal government wants to have it both ways. If I put $19,000 in a box under your Christmas tree, no tax. If I add $1.90 to the cost of the burger you serve me, tax.
Libertarians have long recognized this scam for exactly what it is. Advocates for Self Government even offers a handy dandy card for libertarians to leave with their cash gifts:
"THIS IS NOT A TIP! THIS IS A GIFT. IT IS NOT RENUMERATION FOR EMPLOYMENT NOR COMPENSATION FOR SERVICES. IT IS A GIFT -- FROM ME TO YOU. AS A GIFT, IT IS NOT TAXABLE INCOME."
Since I expect this policy proposal to take a little while (if it passes at all), I just ordered myself a supply.
I already make an extra effort to tip in cash rather than on a card so that hopefully my tips won't be reported or taxed. So should you.
Ending the scam is a great idea. It's basic decency and execution of the clear meaning of the Internal Revenue Code vis a vis "gifts."
Naturally, some disagree. But they have to torture logic beyond repair to justify their disagreement.
(Note: You can view every article as one long page if you sign up as an Advocate Member, or higher).
